Skip to content
Unitify

PayHOA alternatives for self-managed HOAs: Unitify compared

PayHOA is an all-in-one HOA system with its own general-ledger accounting and USPS mailing.

Choose PayHOA if you want the books, bank sync and mailroom in the same system. Choose Unitify if you want homeowners and the board in one resident app, with requests, votes and notices, on a free plan that does not expire; your accountant keeps the books.

PayHOA and Unitify, row by row

PayHOA's public material checked 2026-10-16

What mattersUnitifyPayHOA
PriceStarts at $0: the Free plan is a plan, not a trial, with no card and no expiry, core features and one news post for residents per month. Per apartment per month: Free $0, Base $1, Pro $3, with unlimited users and properties on every plan. Current figures on unitify.com/pricing.Priced by unit band: $49 a month billed yearly ($54 monthly) for 0-25 units, $99 ($109) for 51-100 units, $249 ($275) for 401-500 units, then $0.55 per unit per month with a $275 monthly minimum. A 30-day free trial; the pricing page lists no permanent free plan.1
Collecting dues onlineBilling is an optional add-on, charged only if you switch it on: $0.5 per invoice on Free and Base, free on Pro. Owners pay by card or ACH bank debit through Stripe; ACH settles in up to four business days and is tracked through submission, settlement and return. Payments settle into the association's own connected Stripe account, and Unitify's fee is taken as a separate application fee.Recurring and one-time invoices for dues, fees, fines and late fees, with online payment and autopay. Incoming ACH payments are listed at $2.45 and card payments at 3.5% + $0.50.1,2
AccountingNot an accounting ledger: billing tracks charges and invoices, and your accountant still keeps the books.Full general-ledger accounting with a custom chart of accounts, bank reconciliation, cash and accrual reporting and 50+ report types; a bookkeeping service starts at $199 a month.1,2
Homeowner portalA resident app on every plan: home screen, requests, notices and votes; booking of shared spaces and digital passes from Base. Homeowners add their own home and the administrator verifies each one.Owner portals, described as “a single hub for your homeowners”: payment history, documents and requests in one place.3,4
Voting and surveysThe administrator sets up a vote or survey per building, owners answer in the resident app, and the board sees participation as it arrives. The tool records votes; it does not make a meeting or a vote legally valid.“Voting & Surveys” is a listed feature (“Save time and paper by voting online”); surveys are listed as unlimited on every plan.4,1
Requests and violationsA violation notice or an architectural request comes in as a tracked request with a status, an assignee and a history.Violations and custom request forms are listed as unlimited on every plan, with approval workflows.1
Mailing, website, bookkeeping servicesNot part of Unitify.USPS mailing with printing and postage ($1.25 per first-class letter), a website builder with hosting, bookkeeping from $199 a month and tax filing services (1120-H from $399).1
AI featuresThe AI request classifier on Base; the AI concierge and AI reports on Pro. AI operations are billed in credits (1 credit = $0.01), 500 credits a month included in Pro; the Free plan has none.No public claim of AI features on the home, pricing, features or about pages checked.1,2,3,4
Reviews and scale (PayHOA's own figures)We cite no ratings here; our numbers are in the “Our numbers only” block.Launched 2018, 576,000+ units managed, 6,000+ communities; 4.7 average on 720 Capterra reviews and 280 G2 reviews (all PayHOA's own figures).3,2
Who it is built forOwner-occupied communities run by an association, a board or a management company.Self-managed associations and management companies, with separate pricing for each.1

Why teams choose Unitify

  • A free plan that does not expire: $0 per apartment per month, with no card. PayHOA offers a 30-day free trial and, per its pricing page, then starts at $49 a month billed yearly.
  • The resident app is the center: homeowners file requests, read notices, vote and book shared spaces (from Base) in one app, and the board sees status and participation as they arrive.
  • A per-apartment price ($0 / $1 / $3) with unlimited users and properties on every plan. Free stays $0 at any size; on Base a 100-unit community pays $100 a month.
  • Pay for what you switch on: billing is an add-on at $0.5 per invoice, free on Pro, and AI runs on credits with a monthly spending limit you set.
  • Where our billing runs end to end, in-app payment adoption is measurable: the share of collected payments made in the app at Avant Park rose from 19% in June 2026 to 74% in August 2026.

Our numbers only

Neither building is in the United States; both show what happens when payments and requests live in the resident app.

  • Ande Tower, Batumi: collection of monthly charges rose from 40% to 80% over six months.
  • Avant Park, Baku: the share of collected payments made through the app went from 19% in June 2026 to 74% in August 2026.

What you gain and lose by switching

What you gain with Unitify

  • A free plan with no card and no expiry, instead of a 30-day trial.
  • A resident app on every plan, with requests, notices, votes and booking of shared spaces (from Base).
  • A price per apartment, with billing and AI switched on only if you want them.
  • Records that stay with the association, and an Excel or export import of homes, owners and opening balances.

What you lose by leaving PayHOA behind

  • Full general-ledger accounting in the same system: chart of accounts, bank reconciliation, cash and accrual reports.
  • Bank sync, vendor payables with approvals and a bookkeeping service (from $199 a month) under one login.
  • USPS mailing with printing and postage, and a website builder with hosting.
  • A long track record: launched 2018, with 576,000+ units managed by PayHOA's own count.

When PayHOA is the better fit

  • You want the books inside the HOA system: general-ledger accounting, bank reconciliation, payables with approvals and tax-filing services. Unitify is not an accounting ledger.
  • The board mails paper: USPS printing and postage and mailed checks are listed in the product, and Unitify does not do mailroom work.
  • You want a published price in unit bands for a self-managed HOA, with a bookkeeping service you can add under the same login.
  • A long track record matters most to you: PayHOA states it launched in 2018 and manages 576,000+ units.

Frequently asked questions

What is a PayHOA alternative for a self-managed HOA?

Unitify, if the resident app and a free plan matter more than in-system accounting. A board can start on the Free plan, which is a plan and not a trial, with no card and no expiry, and keep its accountant for the books. If you want the ledger inside the HOA system, PayHOA is built for that.

How much does PayHOA cost?

Its pricing page lists unit bands: $49 a month billed yearly ($54 monthly) for 0-25 units, up to $249 ($275) for 401-500 units, then $0.55 per unit per month with a $275 monthly minimum, plus a 30-day free trial. Unitify costs $0 on Free, $1 on Base and $3 on Pro per apartment per month, with billing as a $0.5-per-invoice add-on that is free on Pro.

What do reviews say about PayHOA?

PayHOA states a 4.7 average on 720 Capterra reviews and 280 G2 reviews (its own figures). We collect no reviews of our own here and cite only what the vendor publishes itself.

Can a self-managed HOA collect dues on Unitify?

Billing is an optional add-on, charged only if you switch it on. Where it is on, it runs the monthly assessment and the reserve contribution and sends the invoice to the resident app; owners pay by card or ACH bank debit through Stripe. ACH settles in up to four business days and is not a guaranteed payment, so Unitify tracks it through submission, settlement and return. Check the payment-processing fees for each rail before comparing them with PayHOA's.

Does Unitify replace our bookkeeping?

No. Billing is not an accounting ledger, so your accountant still keeps the books.

Can we vote online with Unitify?

The administrator sets up a vote or survey for a building, owners answer in the resident app, and the board sees participation as it comes in. The tool records votes; whether a vote is valid depends on your state's law and your governing documents.

Can we move from PayHOA?

Send the registry (homes, owners and opening balances) as an Excel file or an export from your current system, and we set it up with you. Homeowners then add their own home in the app and the administrator verifies each one.

Comparing PayHOA for your HOA?

Add your community on the free plan with no card and no call, and see the resident app on your own homes. Nothing to migrate to evaluate it.